Murder mystery games for 17 to 20 players

Three murder mystery games fit 17 to 20 players: The Sheriff's Missing Moustache, Curtain Call Catastrophe, Sabotage at the Spangle Rink.

Seventeen to twenty players is a full-on event. These three games were written with big casts in mind, so every guest still has a named role, a secret and something the group needs to solve the case.

Games that fit 17 to 20 players

At each player count

Roles and play time by player count
PlayersGameRoles in playPlay time
17The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
17Curtain Call Catastrophe20 suspects120 to 150 minutes
17Sabotage at the Spangle Rink20 suspects130 to 160 minutes
18The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
18Curtain Call Catastrophe20 suspects120 to 150 minutes
18Sabotage at the Spangle Rink20 suspects130 to 160 minutes
19The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
19Curtain Call Catastrophe20 suspects120 to 150 minutes
19Sabotage at the Spangle Rink20 suspects130 to 160 minutes
20The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
20Curtain Call Catastrophe20 suspects120 to 150 minutes
20Sabotage at the Spangle Rink20 suspects130 to 160 minutes

The packet maker on each game page lists the exact pages to print for your player count.

Hosting advice for 17 to 20 players

  • Get a co-host. One person runs the clock and the bell. The other keeps the story moving. Both can still play.
  • Set up stations. Use three or four clue spots around the room so nobody waits in line.
  • Send packets ahead. Share phone links before the day, or hand out paper packets at the door with name tags.
  • Keep announcements short. Big groups lose focus during long speeches. Two minutes, then let them play.
  • Collect accusations on cards. With 20 voices, written accusation cards keep the final round fair and fast. Then read a few out loud for drama.
  • Allow extra time. Arrivals and the reveal take longer with a crowd. Plan about 2.5 hours.

What this adds

Seventeen to twenty players makes a full event, so run it with a co-host, several clue stations and written accusation cards.

Other group sizes

All murder mystery games or the planner.