What to do about no-shows and late arrivals

The short answer: if someone cancels before the party, download the packets for the new player count. If someone does not turn up on the night, use the no-show move list in your host guide: it tells you which of their cards to pass to which players, so the game still works. If someone arrives late, give them the catch-up card for their role and let them join at the next round.

Why this matters in our games

In every MysteryPlot game, each player holds something the group needs. That is what makes every role matter. It also means a missing player could leave a gap. So every game is built with a plan for it, at every player count.

Before the party: someone cancels

If you know in advance, the simplest fix is to switch to the new player count.

  1. Go back to the game page.
  2. Choose the new number of players.
  3. Download the packets again.

In murder mysteries, the story and the solution stay the same at every count. What changes is how the information is shared out. In escape rooms, the number of active wings and teams changes with the count. At smaller counts, characters nobody is playing become statement cards that someone reads aloud, so their information is still in the game.

Check the range. Each game has a minimum number of players. If your new count is below it, the planner can show games that fit.

If you already printed: print fresh packets for the new count. Packets for different counts are not interchangeable, because clues are shared out differently.

On the night: someone does not show up

Sometimes you find out at the door. Do not panic, and do not reprint.

Your host guide has a no-show move list for your player count. It is a short list of instructions. Each line says something like: "If this player cannot come, give this card to that player."

How to use it:

  1. Find the missing player's role in the list.
  2. Take the cards the list names from that player's packet.
  3. Hand them to the players the list names.
  4. Tell the group: "One of our suspects is away tonight. Their statements are on cards, and these players will read them out."

That is it. The move list is designed so that every clue still reaches the table and the game stays solvable.

Two people cannot come

Use the move list for the first missing player, then the second. If several people are missing, it is often easier to switch down to the lower player count, if you have time to download and print. If you are using phone packets, switching counts is quick.

Escape rooms

The idea is the same. Each specialist card holds puzzle pieces. The move list tells you who takes the missing specialist's pieces, so every puzzle still has all its inputs.

Late arrivals

People get stuck in traffic. Our games include a Round 1 catch-up card for every role in murder mysteries.

How to handle a late arrival:

  1. Before they arrive, keep their packet ready and set aside.
  2. When they arrive, give them their packet and the catch-up card. It summarises what their character would have heard in Round 1.
  3. Let them read for two or three minutes in a quiet corner, with a snack.
  4. Bring them in at the start of the next round. Introduce them in character. A dramatic entrance is encouraged.

If you know someone will be very late, check the host guide before you start. It may be simpler to treat them as a no-show for Round 1 and use the move list.

Late to an escape room

Escape rooms are quicker to join. Hand the latecomer their specialist card and point them at their team. Their pieces are often exactly what someone has been waiting for, which makes for a great entrance.

If someone has to leave early

Treat it like a no-show from that point. Ask them to hand their packet to the player named in the move list. If they have already shared their key information, the game can usually carry on as normal.

Hosting tips

  • Confirm numbers two days before. Ask guests to say yes or no clearly.
  • Keep a spare set of name tags. Last-minute changes happen.
  • Read the move list before the party. It takes two minutes and saves stress later.
  • Use print-light if numbers are uncertain. Phone packets are faster to change than paper ones.
  • Follow the list as written. It is worked out for your exact count, so improvising can leave a gap.

A word on fairness

Our games are written so that only the guilty character may lie about the crime. Innocent characters may dodge an embarrassing secret, but they never make up crime facts. When you hand out a missing player's cards, the new reader is reading statements, not playing that character's secrets, so the rules stay fair.

How we write and check games is in our editorial policy.

All how-to guides | Find a game for your group